Skip to content

Bard, Penny and a mini-mailbag

December 29, 2008

Getting to some of your questions (along with some input from site editor Rob Bradford), starting with some thoughts on two players who look like they might be coming to the Red Sox, Josh Bard and Brad Penny.

I didn’t get to know Josh all that well, but what I did know he was a fantastic teammate and great guy. An incredibly hard worker. Anyone that puts up the numbers he did when he went to SD has to be able to hit, more often than not I find when people do that well in short bursts they either have a glaring weakness in their ability to hit, or aren’t confident in their ability to maintain that success over the long haul

Brad is a great kid. I’ve always loved his arm and stuff but also always hoped he’d be able to dial it back a bit. He’s a max effort guy in delivering the ball and he’s helped by the fact that he’s a very big boy. That being said, your arm can only take so much. I think, if he signs here, he could do incredible stuff working with John Farrell. Get him to dial it back about 10-20 percent and he’ll still be throwing low to mid 90’s with command. Add his makeup on the hill to that and you could get one of the more valuable signings of the entire winter since if he’s healthy he’s a #1 or #2 in either league.

(RB: In my dealings with Bard, he seemed like a good guy who was genuinely thrown off by the criticisms he incurred throughout that 10-passed balls month. He admitted after that it got to the point where he was watching video of Doug Mirabelli catching Tim Wakefield to try and emulate him instead of just doing his thing. As for Penny, I’m thinking that being with his buddy, Josh Beckett, and seeing how his work ethic has evolved might translate into a ramped-up regimen.)

Question: Because you may still be playing in 2009 you may not want to answer this question, but what batter did you NOT want to face? Who had your number?

Answer: I just never looked at it like that. Not to mention it’s a question that is totally situation dependant. Runner on third, less than two outs? Guys that don’t strike out, game on the line, one run, no one on? Healthy Vlad, Helton always killed me too.

Question (Ernie): You said that you went up against Boras during a talk show. Was it about Drew not signing with Philly that year? And if so, why would you be against him?

Answer: 1. Yes. 2. Because I was a Philly and was as upset as the fans were at the whole situation. I wasn’t against JD as much as I was against Scott. I, still to this day, cannot fathom how playing independent league, even for a week, puts you in a better position in the future. That money and experience is never regained.

Question: Didn’t Drew, himself, make it clear that he wouldn’t sign for anything less than $10 million, then Philly drafted him anyway and tried to low ball him. Also, isn’t Boras doing his job by trying to get as much money for his client as possible? I mean, people always complain about how players make so much money and they should sign below market deals. But isn’t that just putting more money in the already a billionaire owners pocket? My point is, why shouldn’t an athlete try to get as much money as possible, especially in MLB where you spend 6 years “under control”?

Answer: Not at all, you are 100 percent right. Being right, in this case doesn’t feel good to me. I was wrong in what I said and how I handled it and made that clear to JD a few years ago, apologizing to him. That being said, I still thought the way it all transpired was bad for the game, the player and the fans.

Question (Ben): What’s your honest opinion on Dice K ?

Answer: Relentless. Perfectionist. Absolutely has the ability to win a Cy Young if he can find a way to gain more command of the strike zone. People putting the ball in play don’t fare well against him but it feels like he pitches away from contact, which is really not unusual. Often though, guys that do that get very few decisions and pitch much fewer innings due to huge pitch counts. If Dice gets into a situation where 110-115 pitches gets him through 7 or into the 8th he’s going to win even bigger than last year. BTW his last season was highly overlooked.

Question (John): As a power pitcher, do you see yourself coming back as more of a finesse pitcher?

Answer: Right now I am working out to get to throwing again. Just to see where my arm really is. If Doctor Morgan is correct — and he has been 100% so far — I’ll be better than I was in 2007. The question that remains is how much.  

Question (Jimmie):  Would you like to be a coach or manager in some capacity anywhere in baseball?

Answer: No

(RB: I would)

Question (Bill): Curt, will you and the family remain in the Boston area and continue to be part of the community?

Answer: Yes. We are settled in Medfield and love it here. Not to mention 38 Studios is in Maynard, so we aren’t planning on going anywhere.

Question (Chpln. O’Connell): Do you think Santa will grant my Christmas wish by making the BIG SCHILL pitch one more year for Boston?

Answer: That wish is far beyond Santa or his helpers to assist with.

Question (Pat):  Do you think the Sox would be better off trying to make a play for Russell Martin, who has proven himself in the Bigs and is the catcher of the future, then say trading with one of the Texas catchers or Arizona’s and signing Tek?

Answer: My first choice, were I on the team, would be to have Tek back and grooming his replacement. After that it’s all guesswork. I’ve heard incredible things about Martin and some of the Texas kids but have not seen enough to call that.

(RB: I think  the dream scenario is Taylor Teagarden and Jason Varitek as your catching duo for 2009)

Question (Carlson): Are you a Hall of Famer?

Answer: No

(RB: Yes — Curt, not me.  Post-season success is the difference-maker)

13 Comments leave one →
  1. Doctor X permalink
    December 30, 2008 9:20 am

    Have to agree with RB>; post-season success, particularly consistent post-season success is a difference maker.


  2. Lance permalink
    December 30, 2008 10:46 am

    Quick note, the only people who criticized Bard when he was here was the local media. Never heard a negative word from (intelligent, non-knuckle dragging) fans. The feeling was Theo made a panic move just to appease radio talk who callers and Bard was a legitimate young catcher that could be groomed by Varitek. Too bad they had to trade him the first and here’s hoping this stint is longer and better.

  3. December 30, 2008 12:06 pm

    Just glad you are still active in many areas around here. My family and I loved every aspect of your career and off field activities. You are a great role model for kids and parents, something you should take away with you if you indeed move away. best of luck. Bruce Weinstein

  4. Charles Cody permalink
    December 30, 2008 4:31 pm

    How can you call yourself a real baseball player if you dont play for the Yankees? Just kidding, I am a Yanks fan but I enjoy watching you pitch and enjoy reading what you have to say. Good luck to you and I hope to see you pitching again before you go to the Hall Of Fame.

  5. sdl1 permalink
    December 30, 2008 6:50 pm


    To be honest, I was a bit surprised that they brought Bard back. I figured with Cash gone and with Wakefield staying, somebody like Dusty Brown or George Kottaras, both who’ve caught Charlie Zink at both Portland and Pawtucket would have been the logical (and less expensive) choice to be #2 behind ‘Tek (who I feel will be back).

    Have you had a chance to see any of the PawSox games last season and see either of those two guys?

  6. December 30, 2008 7:59 pm

    Curt…I admire the humility in regards to the HOF question, but I really think this is one time that you don’t need to be humble. Your record in big games and specifically the heroics in 2004 cemented your candidacy.

  7. Babe Ruth permalink
    December 30, 2008 9:59 pm

    So Curt.. You only allow posts of people disagreeing with you on your hof status? That’s funny stuff.

  8. Allen W permalink
    December 30, 2008 10:00 pm

    Hey Curt I disagree with you once again. You are hall of fame material – your entire body of work suggests that you at the very least, have a strong case.

  9. Chris Fiorentino permalink
    December 31, 2008 9:49 am

    I live in Philly, and the entire J.D. Drew situation was ridiculous. Scott Bor-ass showed that his only love is for money, and not the well-being of his player. Drew would have been great in the Minor Leagues for a year, then came up to the bigs, hitting behind Burrell and Rolen, and we may have made a run in the late 90’s. Instead, Bor-ass held him out a year, the idiot Phillies front office traded Schilling for a bag of used baseballs, and the Phillies didn’t recover for 8 years.

    If anyone needs proof of Bor-ass looking out for the money and nothing else, just take a look at the Texas contract for A-Rod. I don’t know about you, but I would rather make ONLY $180 million over 10 years with a winning team than $250 million over 10 years with a bunch of scrubs. Of course, as is typical, the Yankees bailed our A-Rod and traded a young stud(Soriano) for him and, after the guy embarrassed the sport during the World Series, STILL gave him $300+ million. To not hit in the playoffs. Keep up the good work Steinbrenners 🙂

  10. Scott permalink
    January 2, 2009 12:53 pm

    Curt, Bradford is right your post season sucess makes the difference.

  11. Jeff Mills permalink
    January 4, 2009 11:49 pm


    I think that Josh Bard will be a very good acquisition. He had an off-year last year, but he can hit and get on base. Plus, he’s a switch-hitter. As for Penny, I think the jury’s still out on him, but working with John Farrell is a plus. I still remember when him and Beckett were on the Marlins in 2003 and beat the Cubs. Yeah, I’m still having nightmares about that one. (Just kidding.)

    I was just thinking…if the Red Sox acquired Dontrelle Willis, they’d have 3 out of the 5 guys from the 2003 Marlins rotation. And if they picked up Carl Pavano, 4 out of 5.

  12. Dan permalink
    January 7, 2009 9:10 pm

    I’m glad you recognize that you’re not a Hall of Famer.

  13. Jeff Mills permalink
    January 11, 2009 6:15 pm

    If Curt Schilling isn’t a Hall of Famer then Jessica Alba is not attractive. It’s ludicrous to think that Schilling doesn’t belong in Cooperstown IMHO. And I’m not just talking about the “bloody sock” incident. You have to understand and appreciate the numbers that Curt put up in Philly, Arizona and Boston. But Curt’s greatness goes beyond numbers. I do not believe the Diamondbacks would have won the 2001 World Series without Curt Schilling or Randy Johnson. The Yankees had problems with hard throwers that year and Curt and Randy pretty much dominated them. Also, those guys had no fear in them about playing the Yankees or going to Yankee Stadium. And the 2004 Red Sox would not have won the World Series without Curt Schilling. Sure, they needed the whole team, but Curt was a leader, if not, THE leader of that team and his example, his work ethic and leadership were instrumental IMHO in giving that team confidence that they could beat the Yankees. How many other teams have been down 3-0 in the LCS and came back?

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

38 Pitches

Curt Schilling's Official Blog

%d bloggers like this: